In the third quarter of 2026, the median home in Yorkville sold for $830,000. In Lenox Hill, a few blocks west and south, the median was $1,355,000, according to PropertyShark's Yorkville market data and its Lenox Hill page. That is a 63% gap, and it is the number most comparison searches stop at.
Per square foot, the same quarter looks very different. Yorkville's median price per square foot in Q3 2026 was $1,210 and Lenox Hill's was $1,372, so Lenox Hill was about 13% higher. Carnegie Hill's median sale price for the quarter was $2,350,000, 183% above Yorkville's, but its median price per square foot of $1,468 was only about 21% higher.
So most of Yorkville's discount comes from size, not from a cheaper price per square foot. A buyer who compares the two neighborhoods by median price is mostly comparing how large the apartments were that happened to sell. Priced by the square foot on either side of Lexington Avenue, the two neighborhoods are much closer than the medians on the portals suggest.
Both neighborhoods sold the same kinds of homes, at different sizes
You might expect the headline gap to come from a different mix of homes, with Yorkville selling more co-ops and Lenox Hill selling more condos. The Q3 2026 sales do not show that. Co-ops were 114 of Yorkville's 162 recorded deals and 217 of Lenox Hill's 316, about 70% in each neighborhood. The mix of property types was nearly the same.
The co-op prices were not. In Q3 2026, the median Yorkville co-op sold for $682,000 at $882 per square foot. The median Lenox Hill co-op sold for $998,000 at $975 per square foot. The co-op median price was 46% higher in Lenox Hill, while the co-op price per square foot was about 11% higher. Dividing one median by another is rough arithmetic, but it points to the typical Yorkville co-op that traded being roughly 770 square feet, against about 1,000 in Lenox Hill.
Yorkville's own year-over-year numbers show the same pattern. Its Q3 2026 median sale price fell 10.3% from Q3 2025, while its median price per square foot rose 4.9% over the same period. A falling median alongside a rising price per square foot is what you would expect if smaller homes made up more of the quarter's sales.
| Q3 2026 | Yorkville | Lenox Hill | Carnegie Hill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $830,000 | $1,355,000 | $2,350,000 |
| Median price per sq. ft. | $1,210 | $1,372 | $1,468 |
| Condo median, sales | $2.0M, 46 | $1.9M, 91 | $2.9M, 26 |
| Co-op median, sales | $682K, 114 | $998K, 217 | $2.2M, 101 |
Yorkville's condo median now sits above Lenox Hill's
On the condo side, the discount disappeared in Q3 2026. Yorkville's condo median was $2.0 million on 46 sales, up 66.1% from a year earlier. Lenox Hill's was $1.9 million on 91 sales, down 15.5%. With only 46 sales, a single building's closings can move Yorkville's number a long way, and that is what happened this year.
The building is The Strathmore, at 400 East 84th Street. Corcoran's third-quarter 2026 Manhattan market report found that Downtown and East Side sponsor sales together nearly doubled year over year, and it named The Strathmore among the buildings whose closings drove that increase. Units there that went into contract in September 2026 include 31B, 22B and 35C, with last asking prices of $3.20 million, $2.92 million and $4.995 million. A recorded transfer at the address on September 28, 2026 came to $4,977,381. Sponsor sales at those prices pull up a small condo sample very quickly, so the Q3 2026 Yorkville condo median says more about one new building than about what a resale condo on a side street will bring.
The subway premium was priced in years ago
Part of the old reason Yorkville cost less was the walk to the Lexington Avenue line. The Q train extension opened on January 1, 2017, with stations at 72nd, 86th and 96th Streets. Prices near those stations rose while the line was still being finished. In January 2017, Brick Underground reported that condo prices within a block of the three new stations rose 5.12% from 2016 to 2017, compared with 2.66% for Yorkville overall.
The longer view comes from a 2020 Columbia Business School study. It estimated an 8.3% rise in real estate values along the Second Avenue corridor relative to comparison areas, with more tightly controlled building-level and repeat-sales estimates of 2% to 6%. The authors found that roughly half of the gain came through higher rents and half through buyers paying more relative to those rents. Nearly a decade after the line opened, today's price per square foot already includes that gain. The roughly 13% that still separates Yorkville from Lenox Hill per square foot is what remains after the subway premium.
New condos are concentrating around 86th Street
The next several years of Yorkville condo sales will include a run of new buildings, most of them within a few blocks of the 86th Street Q station. As of fall 2026, three new condo projects are planned:
- 175 East 82nd Street: 39 stories and 73 units, with expected asking prices from $3 million to $40 million
- Maison171, at 171 East 86th Street: expected asking prices from $2.5 million to $18 million
- 500 East 81st Street: 10 four-bedroom condos, with expected asking prices from $5.5 million to $11 million
New York YIMBY reported in August 2025 that 171 East 86th Street had reached street level. In October 2026, New York YIMBY reported a plan for 28 condominiums at 1527 York Avenue, also known as 454 East 81st Street, with construction expected to start in early 2027.
Each of these buildings will eventually record sponsor closings, the same kind of sale that lifted Yorkville's condo median this year. The tops of those asking ranges, from $11 million to $40 million, sit well above any of The Strathmore's September figures. If those prices hold, Yorkville's condo figures will reflect new construction for some time. The co-op figures will keep reflecting the older buildings, which make up most of the neighborhood. PropertyShark counts 11,441 co-op units in Yorkville and 6,932 condo units.
Comparing like for like across Lexington
For a buyer deciding between Yorkville and Lenox Hill, the useful comparison is the same type of home at the same size. In Q3 2026, a co-op cost about 11% more per square foot in Lenox Hill than in Yorkville. That is the price of the location itself, separate from apartment size. For condos, it helps to separate new-development and resale prices before comparing either neighborhood. A Yorkville condo median that includes The Strathmore's closings measures a different product from an older resale condo a few blocks away. If the co-op or condo question is still open, it changes the Yorkville math more than the choice of street does.
Comparing like for like also explains why Manhattan-wide numbers can make Yorkville look either cheap or expensive. PropertyShark put the Manhattan median sale price at $880,000 in Q3 2026, slightly above Yorkville's $830,000. But Yorkville's median price per square foot in that quarter was 4.9% higher than a year earlier, and its condo median was above Lenox Hill's. Whether Yorkville looks inexpensive depends on which of these numbers you start from.
Common Questions
Does Carnegie Hill follow the same pattern? Partly. Carnegie Hill's per-foot premium over Yorkville in Q3 2026 was about 21%, far smaller than its 183% gap in median sale price. Unlike Lenox Hill, though, it was higher in both categories, with a $2.9 million condo median on 26 sales and a $2.2 million co-op median on 101 sales. Its co-op median is the clearest example: it was more than three times Yorkville's.
How reliable are quarterly figures for a neighborhood this size? They are reliable enough to show direction, but small. Yorkville recorded 162 sales in Q3 2026, including just 46 condos, so a single building's closings or a few large co-ops can move a median by double digits in one quarter. Price per square foot over several quarters is a steadier guide than any one quarter's median.
If you are weighing a co-op east of Third Avenue against one closer to Park, a conversation about the buildings on your shortlist, measured by price per square foot and recent closings, is a good place to begin. If you already own on the Upper East Side, a home valuation is a way to see your apartment against recent sales of its own type and size. To start, schedule a consultation with Ian Radoncic.